English Cucumber vs. Persian Cucumber: An Expert Explains the Difference
A produce expert teaches us the difference between the two popular cucumbers.
Trending VideosClose this video player
0 of 32 secondsVolume 0%
I love using refreshing cucumbers in salads, quick pickles, sandwiches, and more, and I usually buy whatever looks good or is less expensive at the farmers market or grocery store.
I know I like English cucumbers and Persian cucumbers because of their thin skin, tiny seeds, juiciness, and sweet flavor, and I have noticed that a lot of recipes call for one or the other. But other than the fact that English cucumbers tend to be long, while the Persian ones are usually petite, what else makes them different?
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/Simply-Recipes-Cucumber-Jalapeno-Salad-METHOD-1-4d267f12c7024c568f2f97dfa8aab51c.jpg)
The Difference Between English and Persian Cucumbers
“English and Persian cucumbers both belong to the same species—Cucumis Sativus—and exhibit striking similarities while showcasing a few key distinctions,” Bower says.
“Notably, English cucumbers tend to be larger, averaging around 12 inches in length, while their Persian counterparts are smaller, typically measuring about six inches. In terms of flavor, both varieties share a mild, slightly sweet taste, enhanced by their high-water content that imparts a refreshing mouthfeel and a characteristic crisp bite.”
What sets both apart from slicing cucumbers—the ones with dark green, thick skin—is their thin skin and very small seeds. “Unlike slicing cucumbers, English cucumbers are thinner and boast tiny, immature seeds that are virtually imperceptible, hence earning the term ‘seedless’,” Bower explains. “Persian cucumbers take it a step further with even fewer seeds, rendering both options exceptionally convenient and easy to digest.”
While the typical American slicing cucumber has a thick skin that can taste bitter, is often covered with wax, and is best peeled especially when served raw, neither English nor Persian cucumbers need to be peeled. Bower doesn’t recommend peeling them unless a recipe specifically calls for it.
One way that you can distinguish English cucumbers and Persian cucumbers other than by size is by their packaging at the grocery store. English cucumbers are usually sold individually wrapped in plastic and Persian cucumbers are often found in plastic-wrapped packs of five or six. In my experience, Persian and English cucumbers are typically about the same price by weight.
What Are the Best Uses for English Cucumbers vs. Persian Cucumbers?
“When comparing Persian and English cucumbers, preference is often dictated by the specific culinary application,” says Bower. For example, he says “something magical happens” when you combine English cucumbers and feta cheese. “The saltiness and subtle tanginess of the feta perfectly complement the refreshing coolness and natural sweetness of the cucumber, resulting in the creation of an iconic dish—the Greek salad.”
He also loves English cucumbers in creamy salads with dill, as well as a salad his mother-in-law makes with English cucumbers, mustard, vinegar, heavy cream, and salt and pepper. “My five sons absolutely go bonkers for my mother-in-law’s cucumber salad.”
Because of their shorter length, Persian cucumbers are great for dipping and snacking, says Bowers. “They’re popular among kids for a healthy school lunch alternative,” he adds. He also
Can You Substitute English Cucumbers for Persian Cucumbers and Vice Versa?
Yes. “Since both are very similar in taste and texture, they can be used interchangeably,” says Bowers.
The one time it’s inconvenient to substitute English for Persian cucumbers is when you just need a little cucumber. For example, I prefer to keep Persian cucumbers on hand for my lunchtime salads since I’m usually only making one portion and I can use up a whole cucumber in one go.
3 Reasons Why English Cucumbers Are Wrapped in Plastic
Why is it that some cukes roll around sans-packaging, while my beloved staple variety is confined to a plasticky prison? After a bit of research, I’m happy to report there are very good reasons, and even happier to report that companies are working on eco-friendly alternatives to single-use packaging. Read on to learn why the packaging is so important for English cucumbers.
1. Plastic Wrap Helps Keep Moisture In
English cucumbers have thin skins. This makes them susceptible to losing moisture as they sit on grocery shelves, transforming them from crisp and snappy to tough and bendy. The plastic wrap provides a second skin to keep moisture sealed inside the cucumber for longer.
Between cucumbers stored loose in a resealable bag and those wrapped tightly with plastic wrap, the plastic-wrapped veg outlasted the ones in a resealable bag by twice the amount of time—a full 10 days vs. five days!
The cucumbers in the resealable plastic bag had room to breathe and release moisture—this created a moist environment ideal for housing microorganisms that cause rot. This was not a problem for the tightly wrapped cucumbers.
2. Plastic Wrap Prevents Bruises and Scrapes
An issue with thin-skinned English cucumbers is their propensity to be nicked, scratched, and bruised as they are transported from farm to store. Not only do shoppers prefer unblemished produce, these bumps and scratches can develop mold and rot, one reason why the FDA recommends buying fruit and vegetables that are not bruised or damaged.
3. Plastic Wrap Keeps Decay-Causing Oxygen Out
If you’ve ever worked with or around food, there’s a chance that you’ve had to learn the which stands for the six conditions required for the growth of foodborne pathogens.
The “O” represents oxygen—it accelerates food spoilage as most microorganisms require oxygen to grow and multiply. Oxygen also causes oxidation, which turns the cucumbers brown. Just as the plastic wrap around English cucumbers keeps moisture in, it also keeps oxygen out, therefore slowing the rate of decay.
The Takeaway
Persian and English cucumbers are two excellent varieties of cucumbers. They both have small seeds and thin skin, so they don’t need to be peeled. English cucumbers are much wider and longer than Persian cucumbers, but they both have a mild, sweet, and delicious flavor, so feel free to substitute them for each other in any recipe.
